13 Amazing Anaheim Pepper Substitutes to Spice Up Your Cooking

Looking for the perfect Anaheim pepper substitute to rescue your culinary creation? Look no further! We’ve carefully curated an extensive list of the finest alternatives that will replicate the heat and flavor of Anaheim peppers and elevate your dish to new heights of deliciousness. Intrigued?

Hold tight as we embark on a roller coaster ride through the world of peppers, showcasing mild, medium, and hot Anaheim pepper substitutes and some unexpected and delightful alternatives. By the end of this epic journey, you’ll have the ultimate arsenal of Anaheim pepper substitutes at your fingertips, ready to tackle any recipe that comes your way.


Factors to Consider When Choosing a Substitute

1. Heat level compatibility

When selecting a suitable substitute, consider the heat level. An appropriate replacement should have a similar Scoville rating to maintain the dish’s intended flavor profile. Poblano and Cubanelle peppers have similar SHUs to Anaheim peppers, while jalapeños, serranos, bird’s eye chilies, and cayenne peppers are progressively spicier options.

2. Flavor similarity

A good substitute should possess a flavor reminiscent of Anaheim peppers. While finding an exact match is challenging, aim for alternatives that impart a mild, sweet taste with a hint of earthiness.

3. Availability and accessibility

Opt for readily available substitutes in your area or easily sourced from local markets and grocery stores.

4. Recipe context

Consider the dish you’re preparing and how the substitute will affect the overall taste and texture. Some alternatives may work better in specific recipes, while others may not.

13 Best Substitutes for Anaheim Peppers

1. Poblano peppers: The milder cousin

Anaheim Peppers

With their mild heat and slightly smoky flavor, Poblano peppers make an excellent substitute for Anaheim peppers. Use them in the exact quantities as you would the original ingredient.

Poblanos are an ideal choice for chiles rellenos, salsas, and stews. They can also be roasted or grilled for a deliciously smoky addition to salads and tacos.

2. Cubanelle peppers: A hint of sweetness

Cubanelle peppers

Cubanelle peppers, also known as Italian frying peppers, can replace Anaheim peppers in most recipes. Their slightly sweet and mild taste is a perfect stand-in for the original ingredient.

Also Read:  13 Best substitute for Chili Powder

Cubanelles are great in stir-fries, salads, and stuffed pepper dishes. Their thin walls make them less suitable for roasting or grilling, but they can be sautéed to enhance their natural sweetness.

3. Jalapeño peppers: A versatile choice

Jalapeño peppers

Jalapeño peppers, while spicier than Anaheim peppers, can be a suitable substitute in certain recipes. To reduce heat, remove the seeds and inner membranes before using them.

Jalapeños are a versatile choice for salsas, dips, and sauces. You can also use them in stuffed pepper recipes, pickled, or added to dishes like chili or fajitas.

4. Serrano peppers: A step up in the heat

Serrano peppers

Serrano peppers are considerably hotter than Anaheim peppers. However, they can still be used as a substitute if you’re looking for a spicier kick. Remove the seeds and membranes to tone down the heat, and use sparingly to avoid overpowering the dish.

Serrano peppers are suitable for salsas, guacamole, and hot sauces. You can also dice them and add them to soups, stews, or tacos for an extra burst of heat.

5. Hungarian Wax Peppers

Hungarian Wax Peppers

Hungarian Wax Peppers can be a good substitute for Anaheim Peppers due to their similar appearance, texture, and overall flavor profile. However, there are some differences in heat levels to consider, as Hungarian Wax Peppers tend to be spicier than Anaheim Peppers.

So adjust the substitute quantity accordingly to achieve the desired heat and taste in your dish, ensuring that the overall outcome remains consistent with the original recipe.

6. Thai bird’s eye chilies: A fiery alternative

Thai bird's eye chilies

Thai bird’s eye chilies are significantly spicier than Anaheim peppers. When using them as a substitute, start with a small amount, and adjust according to your heat tolerance. Removing the seeds can also help reduce the spiciness.

These chilies are well-suited for Asian dishes like stir-fries, curries, and noodle recipes. You can use them in spicy salsas or hot sauces for those who enjoy a fiery kick.

7. Cayenne peppers: A spicy kick

Cayenne peppers

Cayenne peppers pack a punch, so use them sparingly when substituting for Anaheim peppers. Removing the seeds can help tame the heat, but be cautious with the quantity to avoid overwhelming the dish.

Also Read:  12 Best Substitutes For Ponzu Sauce

Cayenne peppers can be used in spicy salsas, hot sauces, and chili dishes. They also work well in seasoning blends and dry rubs for meats.

8. Bell Peppers: A Non-Spicy Alternative

Bell Peppers

Bell peppers can be used as a substitute for Anaheim peppers when heat is not a priority. They offer a sweet, mild flavor and can be used in equal amounts as the original ingredient.

Bell peppers work well in stuffed pepper dishes, salads, stir-fries, and fajitas. They can also be roasted or grilled for a sweet, smoky flavor.

9. Dried Anaheim peppers: A concentrated flavor

Dried Anaheim peppers

Dried Anaheim peppers, also known as California chilies or chile seco del norte, offer a more concentrated flavor than their fresh counterparts. Rehydrate them in hot water before using them in recipes.

Dried Anaheim peppers are ideal for salsas, chili sauces, and stews. They can also be ground into powder for seasoning blends and rubs.

10. Ancho chilies: A rich, smoky option

Ancho chilies

Ancho chilies, which are dried poblano peppers, can be rehydrated and used as a substitute for Anaheim peppers. Their rich, smoky flavor adds depth to any dish.

Ancho chilies are excellent in mole sauces, enchiladas, and chili dishes. They can also be ground into a powder for seasoning blends and rubs or used to add a smoky element to salsas and stews.

11. Pepperoncini: A tangy twist


With its tangy and slightly sweet flavor, pepperoncini can be an unconventional substitute for Anaheim peppers. While their taste profile differs, they still provide a mild heat and can be used in recipes that welcome a tangy twist.

Pepperoncini is an excellent addition to salads, sandwiches, and antipasto platters. They can also be used in Greek dishes, such as gyros or Mediterranean-style pasta dishes.

12. Roasted red peppers: A smoky, sweet option

Roasted red peppers

Roasted red peppers, typically made from sweet bell peppers, can be a non-spicy alternative to Anaheim peppers. Their smoky and sweet flavor adds depth to any dish and can be used as much as the original ingredient.

Also Read:  11 Best Substitutes for Red Pepper Flakes

Roasted red peppers are a delightful addition to pasta dishes, sandwiches, salads, and dips, like hummus or baba ganoush. They can also be used in casseroles, stews, or as a topping for pizza and bruschetta.

13. Exploring Pepper Blends and Mixes

Mixing various pepper types allows you to create a customized flavor profile tailored to your preferences. You can achieve a perfect balance that suits your taste buds by combining peppers with different heat levels and flavors.

Start with a base of mild peppers, like poblanos or bell peppers, and then add medium or hot peppers, such as jalapeños or serranos, to increase heat. Adjust the proportions until you reach the desired flavor and heat intensity.

Incorporating Anaheim Pepper Substitutes in Global Cuisine

1. Mexican dishes: Salsas, chiles rellenos, and more

Substitutes like poblanos, jalapeños, and serranos can be used in traditional Mexican dishes, such as salsas, chiles rellenos, and enchilada sauces, to impart a similar flavor profile to Anaheim peppers.

2. Indian recipes: Curries, pickles, and spice blends

Hotter substitutes, like bird’s eye chilies or cayenne peppers, can be used in Indian cuisine to add heat to curries, pickles, and spice blends.

3. Asian cuisine: Stir-fries, noodle dishes, and dipping sauces

Thai bird’s eye chilies and other hot pepper substitutes can be incorporated into Asian dishes, such as stir-fries, noodle dishes, and dipping sauces, to add a spicy kick and depth of flavor. Be cautious with the quantities to avoid overpowering the dish.

In summary, there are several suitable substitutes for Anaheim peppers, including:

  1. Mild substitutes: Poblano peppers and Cubanelle peppers
  2. Medium heat substitutes: Jalapeño peppers and Serrano peppers
  3. Hot substitutes: Thai bird’s eye chilies and Cayenne peppers
  4. Non-spicy alternative: Bell peppers
  5. Dried substitutes: Dried Anaheim peppers and Ancho chilies
  6. Creative alternatives: Pepperoncini and Roasted red peppers

Now that you’re equipped with various Anaheim pepper substitutes feel free to experiment and explore new flavors and heat levels in your culinary creations. Remember, the key to great cooking is creativity and a willingness to try new things. Happy cooking!

Scroll to Top