Aji Amarillo plant

12 Delicious Aji Amarillo Substitutes to Spice Up Your Recipes

Aji Amarillo paste is a true gem in the world of culinary delights. Its unique fruity, citrusy flavor and the perfect balance of heat add a delightful twist to many recipes. However, we’ve all been in that situation where we’re ready to whip up a delicious meal, only to realize that we’re missing a crucial ingredient.

Fear not, fellow foodies! If you find yourself without Aji Amarillo paste, there’s no need to panic. In this article, we’ll explore some fantastic substitutes that will save the day and allow you to create mouth-watering dishes without missing a beat.


12 Delicious Aji Amarillo Substitutes to Spice Up Your Recipes

1. Chipotle Peppers

chipotle peppers

Chipotle peppers are an excellent choice if you’re looking for a smoky, spicy substitute for Aji Amarillo paste. Made from smoked jalapeƱos, they add depth and complexity to sauces, salsas, marinades, and more. While they differ from Aji Amarillo in their smokiness, they still kick your dishes deliciously. Start with a small amount and adjust to taste, considering the smoky flavor.

2. Habanero Peppers

Habanero Peppers

For those who can handle the heat, habanero peppers offer a flavorful alternative to Aji Amarillo paste. Known for their fierce heat and fruity tang, these peppers add both color and zing to your dishes. Remember to use caution when substituting Aji Amarillo paste with habanero peppers, as they pack quite a punch. Start with a small amount and adjust according to your taste preferences.

3. Manzano Peppers

Manzano Peppers

Manzano peppers are a unique Aji Amarillo paste substitute, offering a similarly sweet, citrusy taste and summer-yellow hue. While slightly less spicy than Aji Amarillo chilis, their heat level ranges from 12,000 to 30,000 SHU, making them a suitable alternative. These peppers might be harder to find, but they are worth the search for their delightful flavor.

Also Read:  13 Best Substitutes for Cayenne Pepper

4. Scotch Bonnet Peppers

Scotch Bonnet Peppers

Another spicy option for those who can handle the heat, scotch bonnet peppers can be used in place of Aji Amarillo paste. They are similar to habaneros but might be more challenging to find outside of Caribbean countries. Regardless, they add a unique and fiery touch to any dish.

5. Serrano Peppers

Serrano Peppers

Serrano peppers make for a milder Aji Amarillo paste substitute, with a heat level of 10,000 to 23,000 SHU. These peppers are becoming increasingly common in grocery stores and can be used in various dishes, adding a fresh and moderately spicy flavor.

6. Piquante Peppers

Piquante peppers, also known as Peppadew peppers, offer a sweet and tangy flavor with mild heat. They can be an excellent substitute for Aji Amarillo paste, especially when looking for a less spicy option. Piquante peppers work well in salads, pasta dishes, or even as a topping for pizza.

7. Criolla Sella

Criolla Sella peppers, originating from Bolivia, provide a fruity, citrusy flavor with a hint of spiciness. They are an excellent alternative to Aji Amarillo paste, adding a unique flavor to your dishes while still offering a bit of heat. Criolla Sella peppers can be used in salsas, sauces, and other recipes that call for Aji Amarillo paste.

8. Cheongyang Chili Pepper

Cheongyang Chili Pepper

The Cheongyang chili pepper, a popular ingredient in Korean cuisine, offers a spicy kick similar to Aji Amarillo paste. With its heat level ranging from 10,000 to 23,000 SHU, this pepper is a suitable substitute for those who enjoy a bit of spice in their dishes.  Cheongyang chili peppers can be used in a variety of recipes, from stir-fries to soups.

These peppers are spicy, so you might want to use fewer peppers or combine them with a milder pepper for a balanced heat. Adjust the sweetness and tanginess as needed to match the Aji Amarillo flavor.

Also Read:  11 Best Substitutes For Chipotle Powder

9. Guntur Chili

Guntur Chili

Guntur chili, hailing from India, is another spicy alternative to Aji Amarillo paste. Known for its fiery heat and deep red color, this chili adds a punch to any dish. Guntur chili can be used in curries, stews, and other dishes where a burst of heat is desired. These chilies are quite spicy, so use them sparingly and consider combining them with milder peppers for a well-rounded flavor profile. The paste might need extra sugar to balance the heat.

10. Aleppo Pepper

Aleppo Pepper

The Aleppo pepper, named after the city of Aleppo in Syria, offers a fruity, mildly spicy flavor that can serve as a substitute for Aji Amarillo paste. The pepper is commonly found in the form of dried flakes or powder, making it easy to incorporate into various dishes like soups, stews, and sauces.

11. Fresno Pepper

Fresno Pepper

Fresno peppers, similar in appearance to jalapeƱos, provide a mild to moderate heat level with a slightly sweet flavor. They make for a great Aji Amarillo paste substitute when you’re looking for a milder option. Roasting them can help bring out their natural sweetness, making them an excellent substitute. Fresno peppers can be used in salsas, sauces, and other dishes where you want to add a touch of heat without overpowering the other flavors. 

12. Bishop’s Crown Pepper

Bishop's Crown Pepper

Also known as the Christmas Bell pepper, Bishop’s Crown pepper is an intriguing option for substituting Aji Amarillo paste. This uniquely shaped pepper offers a mild heat level and a fruity, slightly sweet taste. They are milder and fruitier than Aji Amarillo, so consider using more of them or combining them with a spicier pepper to achieve the desired heat level. Roasting the peppers can enhance their fruity flavor. It can be used in various dishes, including salads, stir-fries, and sauces, to add a touch of spice and an interesting visual element.

Also Read:  5 Substitutes for Vanilla Beans

Factors to Consider When Substituting for Aji Amarillo Paste

When substituting for Aji Amarillo paste, there are several factors to consider to ensure the best possible outcome for your dish. These factors include:

1. Heat level

Aji Amarillo peppers have a heat level ranging from 30,000 to 50,000 Scoville Heat Units (SHU). When substituting, consider the heat level of the substitute you choose and adjust the quantity accordingly to match your desired spiciness.

2. Flavor profile

Aji Amarillo peppers have a fruity, slightly sweet, and citrusy flavor. When choosing a substitute, look for peppers or pastes with a similar flavor profile to maintain the dish’s overall taste.

3. Texture

Some substitutes may have a different texture than Aji Amarillo paste. For instance, using fresh or dried pepper instead of paste might require additional blending or processing to achieve a similar consistency.

4. Color

Aji Amarillo paste has a vibrant yellow-orange hue. If the color is essential to your dish’s presentation, consider selecting a substitute with a similar color or adjust the other ingredients to balance the final appearance.

5. Availability

Depending on your location, some substitutes might be more accessible than others. Check your local grocery stores, specialty markets, or online retailers for the availability of potential substitutes.

In conclusion, finding the perfect Aji Amarillo paste substitute may seem challenging at first, but as we’ve seen, there are plenty of great alternatives to choose from. Each substitute offers its unique flavor profile and heat level, allowing you to experiment with your dishes and find the one that best suits your taste buds. Happy Cooking!

Scroll to Top